I. Introduction
As we know when a teacher asks his or her students to speak in English, most of them can not do it directly because they feel so worried for their pronunciation, vocabulary and grammar. This happens and continues in their daily life. They always feel so shy and lack of self- confidence to speak in English not only in the teaching-learning process but also when they meet somebody from country abroad who speaks in English, such as American, Australian or British. That is why we as English teacher should design any activities which facilitate them to dare in speaking not only in teaching-learning process but also in real- situation.
One of the crucial issues to facilitate students to dare in speaking English is the use of computer equipped with multimedia software packages. It serves the students to listen, record and playback for accuracy and pronunciation practices. It also helps them to increase their self-confidence to speak to people in real-situation after they do regular practice. In application, a teacher is not busy to check the students because the task will be done by computer including giving the responses either appraisal or suggestion.
In this essay, the writer would like to show the readers that the use of computer can enhance the students’ speaking skill. To support the argument, the writer presents review of related literature for example the role of computer in teaching and what kinds of aspect in speaking skill that computer serves. The writer also presents analysis showing the strengths and the weaknesses of using computer in teaching speaking skills.
II. Objective
There are two objectives of this essay:
1. To show the teachers that computer can facilitate the students to learn English, especially in speaking skill.
2. To encourage the teachers to use computer to enhance the students’ speaking skills.
III. Review of Related Literature
Hartoyo (2006) writes that computer has two roles in learning:
1. Computer as a medium for facilitating people in learning, such as learning language
2. Computer as a more interactive aid compared with other media
It is helpful to think of the computer as having the following main roles in the language classroom:
• teacher – the computer teaches students new language
• tester – the computer tests students on language already learned
• tool – the computer assists students to do certain tasks
• data source – the computer provides students with the information they need to perform a particular task (http://esl.fis.edu/teachers/support/teach.htm)
It is clear from the opinions above that computer can be used as media in learning language because it has more complete features than other media, such as, tape recorder, VCD and DVD. In addition, it also serves students several things. First, it can let the students listen to dialogues or watch video clips. They can click on pictures to call up the names of the objects they see. They can speak into the microphone and immediately hear a recording of what they have said. The program can keep a record of their progress, e.g. the vocabulary learned, and offer remedial help if necessary. Second, it can serve the students drill and practice; it will tirelessly present them with questions and announce if the answer is right or wrong. Third, it can be used as a writing tool because it has played a significant part in the introduction of the writing process, by allowing students easily to produce multiple drafts of the same piece of work. Students with messy handwriting can now do a piece of work to be proud of, and those with poor spelling skills can, after sufficient training in using the spell check, produce a piece of writing largely free of spelling mistakes. Forth, it can serve encyclopaedias, that present information in a more compact, reliable and easily accessible form.
Having known many good sides of computer in language learning, it is possible for the teachers to use computer for developing the students’ speaking skills. As Pennington (1989) writes that computers can provide instruction in speaking and listening in two general ways: (1) They can create environments which facilitate interaction, and (2) They can provide training in production and perception of speech. Similarly, Kenning (1984) claims that computer can be utilized to enhance language learning, and can also be used to generate examples to illustrate certain operations, or to stimulate conversation. In fact, application of computer in teaching and learning speaking is mainly decided by the nature of speaking itself. Looking at the points of view from Pennington and Kenning, we can understand that using of computer to emphasize the development of speaking skill can be very helpful to improve the listening skills because when the teacher asks the students to deal with the computer which is equipped with multimedia software packages. According to Pennington (1995), spoken language competence covers two aspects, i.e. the mechanical aspect and the meaningful aspect, which are summarised as follows:
1. Mechanical aspect is learning to discriminate and produce sounds of a language and tie these together prosodically in fluent strings of sounds comprising syllables, words, phrases and longer utterances or articulation and decoding of individual sounds (phonemes)
2. Meaningful aspect is learning to build as well as to decompose grammatically coherent utterances and to tie these to communicative functions according to rules of pragmatic appropriateness in a given speech community.
In teaching speaking skills by using computer, there are some alternative programs of CALL that teachers can use, such as CMC (computer mediated communication) and SLIM (Multimedia Interactive Linguistic Software).
According to Herring (1996) CMC can be defined as “communication that takes place between human beings via the instrumentality of computers”. As Harasim (1990); Berge and Collins (1995) claim that CMC has been proved by many researchers to have a critical impact on higher education and positive changes in face-to-face classroom interactions. It also supported by Collison, Elbaum et al. (2000) that CMC has become a relatively easy-to-adopt tool for educators around the world. CMC is strongly recommended to be used in improving students’ pronunciation and practicing discussion and argument.
SLIM (Multimedia Interactive Linguistic Software) developed at the University of Venice, in which the Prosodic Module has been created in order to deal with the problem of improving a student’s performance both in the perception and production of prosodic aspects of spoken language activities, tackling phonetic and prosodic problems at the word and segmental level, and with prosodic aspects at phonological phrase and utterance supra segmental level.
(http://www.edfac.unimelb.edu.au/research/resources/student_res/postscriptfiles/vol3/vol3_1_gong1.pdf)
As Delmonte (2000) says that SLIM is able to detect significant deviation from a master’s word/phrase/utterance production and offers visual aids and a written diagnosis of the problem as well as indications on how to overcome and correct the error.
In using of the compute related to CALL program such as CMC or SLIM makes the students learn pronunciation. According to Pennington (1995), since speech analysis technology is highly motivating, even learners who had formerly shown no inclination to work on their pronunciation will often willingly spend time working alone or with a trainer using this computer-based form of input and practice. It can be understood that using the computer in learning pronunciation can offer a private environment without fear of the number of repetitions needed for full comprehension or accuracy of production. Furthermore, the students’ worry and embarrassment about phonetic inaccuracies are greatly reduced. In addition, they can always adjust their own pace of learning. Besides learning pronunciation, the students can learn to practise some dialogues where the students can talk to the computer. For example, one program named Conversations offers 14 dialogues in which the students can participate. This program features two speakers, and the students can take the part of either. Such software always covers practical language functions and various topics.
It also allows learners to choose a situation, study the dialogue, record themselves and then play the recording back and compare it to the model. The software with speech recognition and analysis functions can even give learners visual feedback.
IV. Analysis
In this section, the writer would like to present an analysis about the strengths and the weaknesses of using computer in teaching speaking skills. As we know that computer environment has great advantages for the students to develop speaking skills which provides safe, motivating and interactive environment, a great variety of resources, spontaneous feedback, exposure to real interaction, addresses to different need, and lets controllability over the rate of learning. Though many advantages of using computer in teaching-learning speaking skills can be gained, we really need to understand the strengths and the weaknesses.
The strengths of using computer to enhance speaking skills are:
1. As Kataoka (2000) says that many learners feel more confident when they practise speaking using computers than in face-to-face settings. It is supported by Pennington (1996) who has argued, computer training systems for pronunciation seem to be one of the few environments where learners’ consciousness of their own spoken language errors does not interfere with their learning. From both opinions above, we can draw conclusion that learning speaking skills by using computer can improve the students’ self-confidence to pronounce or talk to the computer as if they make a dialogue and reduce their anxiety in making errors. In addition, they can realize their own mistakes from the feedback the computer gives without feeling ashamed or annoyed like they get correctness from their teacher or their friends.
2. The material that can be displayed in the computer always be more authentic and interesting because it provides not only texts like a book but also graphics, sound files, digitised audio and video clips, etc.
3. It offers the controllability of materials and self-teaching system. In the controllability of materials, the computer allows learners to proceed learning at their own pace and teachers to arrange their teaching to meet different needs. The computer which serves as a self-teaching system can help the adjustment the level of the task to fit the students’ ability level. Here, the teachers can address different learning styles of their students through multimedia with pictures, sound, movies and texts offering different ways to deal with the same materials to suit various learning styles, which help to personalise individual student’s learning. In addition, in a normal teaching situation, it is impossible for teachers or native speakers to repeat a phrase without variation in its utterance or repeat as much as the students want them to. Therefore the controllability of the computer environment makes teaching and learning more flexible and personalized.
4. The materials can offer spontaneous feedback that can be used both for assessment or self-assessment purposes.
5. It is possible to have networked computer which enhances interaction between users and the target language content, by putting learners in touch with other learners or native speakers of the language, and a multitude of other resources free from the restriction of time and distance.
The weaknesses of using computer to enhance the students’ speaking skills are:
1. The computer can not serve a natural language or real verbal interaction unlike the teachers do with the students in teaching-learning process.
2. The computer only creates “virtual” environment unlike the “real” one where the teacher and the students can make direct contact. In other words, it can not replace actual human-to-human contact in learning a language.
3. It has possibility to set the teachers’ mind that they can learn speaking skills, such as how to pronounce words or sentences and how to have a dialogue because of the computer. It can occur since the teacher has less direct involvement when the students do practice or have a test with the computer.
V. Summary and recommendation
CMC or SLIM supporting computer can be a promising medium for the teaching and learning of speaking skills. The programs can help the teachers to assist or facilitate their students to practise without being interfered, ashamed or discouraged; in the other words, the students feel more confident and realize their strengths and weaknesses when the computer gives the feedback.
Considering the numbers of strengths more than the numbers of weaknesses in using computer to enhance the students’ speaking skills, it is better for every teacher to change the way he or she teaches. It means today is the time for the teacher to make a use of computer with multimedia software packages, such as CMC or SLIM in facilitating his or her students to learn speaking skills in challenging way.
References:
1. Hartoyo. 2005. Individual Differences: in Computer- Assisted Language Learning (CALL). Semarang. UPT UNNES Press
2. _____, The employment of CALL in teaching second/foreign language speaking skill. http://www.edfac.unimelb.edu.au
3. _____, Teaching Speaking Skills at a Vietnamese University and Recommendations for Using CMC. http://www.asian-efl-journal.com
4. _______, Using computers in language teaching. http://esl.fis.edu.
5. _______.2004. Speaking in the CALL Environment. http://www.paccall.org
6. _______. Advantages and disadvantages of using computer network technology in language teaching. http://js.vnu.edu.vn
7. _______.Teaching speaking, listening and writing.http://www.ibe.unesco.org
8. _______.Using Web Resources in a Public Speaking Class. http://exchanges.state.gov
9. ________.Information and Communication Technologies
http://wwwfp.education.tas.gov.au